Total Pageviews

Thursday, March 5, 2009

Politics and political afflictions

A former Chief Election Commissioner observed sometime back that “politicians are the cancer of society”. It is indeed possible to build further on politics as a metaphor for the disease - a familiar literary device from Homer’s Iliad to Camus’La Peste –that is responsible for the many of the dysfunctions of our society.

Politics owes its current morbidity to the original sin of cohabitation with crime in order to gratify its desire for electoral success and subsequent generations have acquired this illicit lust, which is both indiscriminate and indiscreet. The criminal element in politics has metastasized over the years and has now become firmly implanted in the bone marrow of politics. Cancer evokes a feeling of helplessness, of resignation and an existentialist terror in those who are condemned to watch it take its toll of their loved ones. Despite our ritual expression of horror, people accused of murder, rape etc are being courted by all the political parties for the forthcoming parliamentary elections. The civil society finds itself less and less able to count on its antibodies – the institutions, whether formal or informal- because the sentinels themselves have deserted or stand compromised.

On the eve of elections to the various legislative bodies the political arena almost presents the scene of an asylum for victims of senile dementia. Old friends pass each other by as strangers, while implacably hostile enemies hug each other; promises of eternal friendships sours in three days flat, and alliances are made and unmade several times during the course of one electoral season. The consequences of this promiscuity could be perceived as comical were it not for the fact that it concerns such a vital aspect of our lives. In the manner of seasonal transfer of players of the professional soccer league, newly inducted political players are inaugurated on the prime time. In its naiveté or diabolic crookedness –politics believes that the itinerant travelers of the whole political landscape – many of them have traveled from extreme right to leftist extremism and vice versa -are like so much malleable putty, capable of being moulded into any shape, or so many tabula rasa on which you could inscribe any ideology. Like so many robots they are programmable for any performance. The baptismal waters of their new faith debugs them instantly and their memory is erased for being formatted anew.

When confronted with basic issues politics tends to look side ways in an uncomprehending manner or ramble in an incoherent muddled sort of way. How does politics justify the expenditure of such astronomical sums of money on these gladiatorial contests called elections, seasonally and sometimes unseasonably as well, while 300 million of our people live below poverty line? Where do the funds come from? The financial status and criminal antecedents of the contestants, the performance report in respect of earlier promises are issues that are recognized but evaded with cunning and disingenuousness that sometimes characterizes the patients of schizophrenia. Or it resorts to some singularly idiotic arguments. Charged with financial misconduct or corrupt practice its stock response is that worse immorality has been seen. Popular verdict is accorded a sacerdotal value and electoral success is touted as exoneration from guilt as well as investiture with civic virtues.

Political discourse, consequently has itself acquired a hothouse atmosphere. Critical debate has given way to bellicose gestures. Incantatory formula does regular duty for a detailed and rational exposition. Insinuations, innuendoes and invectives are the weapons freely used to occupy the moral high ground. Each one of them has a “secret plan” which the other is somehow aware of - whether to destabilize the government, fracture the unity of the country, or subvert the cause of social justice; (Foreign hand is a flavour that is out of favour this season! ). It is impossible to list out all the insecurities of a paranoid mind. Unsure about the most vital points of their self-definition they define themselves in terms of opposition to the other. So a secular alliance is the one, which does not have anti-secular elements in it. Some other alliance may declare itself to be the sole custodian of both ideology and memory precluding the possibility of any debate. Very often no party is in a position to frame clear issues of public policy, which can be debated without reference to the a priori culpabilities of the Other, or categories of exclusion. It is much easier to catch people’s attention by appealing to their prejudices ignorance or insecurity rather than their reason. So these weaknesses are not only pandered to but also systemically inculcated in its particular constituency. The illusory, irrational quality of political debate becomes deathly real only when elected representatives sometimes get physical in the august precinct of the house.

Myopia again is the easiest affliction to manage. One can get a suitable pair of glasses. But the debilitated contemporary politics, finds itself unable to walk to the nearest optician. Instead it chooses to reduce the world to its myopia. The perspective on future is condensed to the next election and on many an issue of grave importance, its thinking shows the same tawdry, Lilliputian character. No wonder that politics fails to read the writing on the wall, clear to even someone with a vision of 6/60, that prohibition against cohabitation with crime is no longer a moral injunction but a medical necessity.

The Age of Reason recognized the relation between social environment and physical well being which revolutionized our thinking on hygiene and cleanliness in our personal lives as well as our physical environment. It is to be hoped that the widespread disaffection with criminal politics will be similarly translated into some activism in the realm of moral and intellectual hygiene in the public sphere. The hundreds of millions of the voters of the country could certainly impose an effective quarantine against crime, fumigate the contaminated public spaces and start all over again. The new millennium justifies this millinery hope.

8 comments:

Ritu said...

Dear Sir

First of all, I wish to express my admiration for your writings and fearless expression of your sentiments in this day and age. I have been following your attempts to do some honest good work in Bihar including the latest expose of BSEB chairman. I wish you all the best in your endeavours. You are actually doing what many of us Biharis have been dreaming of (and keep dreaming). I am going to popularise your musings among my like minded Indian friends , so you may see a sudden surge of interest in this site.

Kind Regards
Ritu

Manoje Nath said...

hi ritu,
First an apology.I have not myself visited my blog for the past many days .I have been so much under pressure I just find time to come up for air. But it is hugely encouraging to know that some one in some distant corner of the world is concerned about such small little efforts .Especially, if the concerned person is young and has so much to occupy her. Some years back I wrote an edit piece in the Indian Express Bihar needs a Bihari Pill The response was overwhelming. Along with very constructive, very sagacious advice came offers for cash .I’ll say today what I told my many correspondents then – concern not cash is what Bihar needs even today. thanks again for your kind words.

The current post was written sometime back but I could not find time to publish it.

ajoyipsbhr85 said...

the Politicians are not to be blamed for the problems facing our country...
a political worker would retire as a political worker, if he does not learn the trick of the trade... he has to create room for himself up the ladder... and has to adopt "ooper chato, neeche kato" strategy...
if he had money to survive, he would not be spending his days as flag bearer.. so he has to arrange money also, for his family... and has to pester his political guru to arrange for some money....
this compels the MLA to have MLA fund... and this compulsion travels further...
it is a jungle out there, and everybody is a permanent enemy, and survival is most difficult....
but for the "caste", there are no weapons to bring down an adversary...
the politician does not get to taste power immediately... he has to die a thousand deaths before tasting power....
unless there is public spending on political activities [for which modalities have to be worked out] and direct election of the Chief Executive, there can be no honesty in politics....
and we may not agree, but our Constitution has given us a system, that cannot give us an honest polity....
it is time to start discussing the Constitution.... although as public servants, we have sworn by it....
our duties as citizen have not conflict with that of the public servant, we have a duty to formulate the views and educate the masses....
and when the Institutions like the NPA and BPR&D are not prepared to shoulder this responsibility, we have to go it alone.....
we cant blame it on any one, politicians are as much victims of this system, as anyone else....
the system needs improvement... and criticism doesn't need to be generalized....
we have also failed to create a safe environment for our daughters and sisters, as Ruchika's case has shown us all, can we be blamed for everything that bothers this nation...?
thought has to be given on the solution suggested above... and the earlier your views are formed and posted, the better it is for the nation.....
posting keep coming and going, but the citizenship is permanent, and patriotic duty must be performed, at all costs...

Anonymous said...

pretty cool stuff here thank you!!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

Thank you for that entry. I nearly passed your weblog up in Yahoo but now I'm glad I checked it out and obtained to go as a result of it. I'm undoubtedly a tiny better informed now. I know very a couple of individuals which will wish to examine it out. They'll for sure take pleasure in the heck out of what I just study too.

Anonymous said...

Lots of beneficial reading here, thank you! I had been searching on yahoo when I discovered your post, I’m going to add your feed to Google Reader, I look forward to additional from you.

Anonymous said...

When I found your blog was like wow. Thank you for putting your effort in publishing this site.

Sanjay said...

Who is this son-of-God former CEC who picked up courage to speak after enjoying the fruits and spoils of his 40-year long bureaucratic life. One reader has aptly commented "ooper chato, neeche kato" - LICK ABOVE, KICK BELOW. God save us from such wretched creatures. This country is doomed and has dismal future, despite whatever people may say.